How do I know if a wine is “corked” or flawed?

As a wine enthusiast, one of the most important skills to develop is the ability to identify when a wine is “corked” or flawed. In this article, we’ll explore the most common flaws in wine, how to recognize them, and what to do if you encounter a corked or flawed wine.

Corked Wine: The Telltale Signs

A “corked” wine is one that has been tainted by a chemical compound called TCA (2,4,6-trichloroanisole), which can result from the natural cork closure used to seal the bottle. Not all wines with cork closures will suffer from cork taint, but it is a common enough issue that every wine enthusiast should know how to recognize the signs. Here are the main indicators of a corked wine:

  • Aroma: A corked wine often exhibits a musty, moldy, or damp cardboard smell. This aroma can be subtle or pronounced, depending on the severity of the taint.
  • Flavor: The taste of a corked wine may be dull, flat, or muted, with the wine’s natural fruit flavors being overshadowed by the off-putting mustiness. In severe cases, the corked flavor can make the wine undrinkable.
  • Visual Clues: While the appearance of the wine may not always indicate a corked wine, some corked bottles may have a discolored or damaged cork, which can be a clue to potential contamination.

It’s important to remember that a corked wine is not harmful to consume, but it can be an unpleasant experience due to the off-putting aromas and flavors.

Other Common Wine Flaws

Cork taint is not the only issue that can affect a bottle of wine. There are several other common wine flaws that you should be aware of:

  • Oxidation: Oxidation occurs when wine is exposed to excessive amounts of oxygen, either due to a faulty closure or improper storage. Oxidized wines often have a flat or stale taste, with the fruit flavors being replaced by nutty or Sherry-like notes. The color of the wine may also change, with white wines appearing more golden or brown, and red wines losing their vibrant hue.
  • Volatile Acidity (VA): VA is caused by the presence of acetic acid, which can give the wine a sharp, vinegar-like aroma and taste. This flaw is typically the result of bacterial spoilage during the winemaking process. In small amounts, volatile acidity can add complexity to a wine, but when the levels are too high, the wine becomes unpalatable.
  • Brettanomyces (Brett): Brett is a type of yeast that can cause a variety of off-flavors in wine, ranging from barnyard, horse blanket, or band-aid aromas to smoky or medicinal notes. Like volatile acidity, a small amount of Brett can add complexity, but excessive levels can spoil the wine.
  • Heat Damage: Wine exposed to high temperatures during storage or transportation can become “cooked,” resulting in a loss of freshness and a stewed fruit flavor. Signs of heat damage include a pushed-up cork, seepage around the cork, and a cooked or jammy taste.

What to Do If You Encounter a Flawed Wine

If you suspect that your wine is corked or flawed, follow these steps:

  • Compare: If possible, compare the wine in question to another bottle of the same wine or a similar wine to help you determine if the off flavors and aromas are truly indicative of a flaw.
  • Educate Yourself: Use the experience as a learning opportunity to become more familiar with the various wine flaws and how to recognize them. The more you understand these issues, the better equipped you’ll be to identify them in the future.
  • Return the Bottle: If you’ve purchased a corked or flawed wine from a reputable retailer, don’t be afraid to return it. Most wine shops and restaurants are understanding of these issues and will typically offer a replacement or refund.
  • Share Your Experience: Discuss the flawed wine with friends, family, or fellow wine enthusiasts to learn from each other’s experiences and expand your collective knowledge.

Being able to identify a corked or flawed wine is an essential skill for any wine enthusiast. Familiarize yourself with the common wine flaws, their causes, and their characteristics to enhance your understanding and appreciation of wine. Remember that encountering a flawed wine is not a reflection of your taste or judgment, but rather an opportunity to learn and grow as a wine lover. By recognizing and addressing these issues, you’ll be better prepared to fully enjoy the wide world of wine that awaits you.

Take a quiz to test your knowledge

Written by

Bernard Marr has a deep passion for wine. He has written hundreds of articles on wine, including features for Forbes, covering wine-making and industry trends. Away from the world of wine, Bernard is a world-renown business and technology futurist. He is the award winning author of over 20 best-selling books and has a combined audience of nearly 4 million people across his social media channels and newsletters.

Wine Sections

Tasting and Enjoying Wine | Bernard Marr | Wine Cellar

Tasting & Enjoying Wine

Understanding Wine Making | Bernard Marr | Wine Cellar

Understanding Wine Making

Understanding Wine Regions | Bernard Marr | Wine Cellar

Understanding Wine Regions

Understanding Grape Varieties | Bernard Marr | Wine Cellar

Understanding Grape Varieties

Understanding Wine Labels | Bernard Marr | Wine Cellar

Understanding Wine Labels

The Wines of the World | Bernard Marr | Wine Cellar

The Wines of the World

Wine Trends & Technology | Bernard Marr | Wine Cellar

Wine Trends & Technology

Wine and Food Pairing | Bernard Marr | Wine Cellar

My Wine Adventures

Wine & Food Diary | Bernard Marr | Wine Cellar

Wine and Food Pairing

Wine Reviews | Bernard Marr | Wine Cellar

Wine Reviews

Some of my most memorable wines